Facebook Twitter eEdition Your News Business Directory List Business Classifieds Subscribe NEMisJobs NEMissPreps NEMSHomes NEMSDeals

POINT/COUNTERPOINT: Which wrong-headed policies has spill exposed?
by James Hull and Ed Holliday
23 months ago | 635 views | 6 6 comments | 6 6 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Point by James Hull

Am I the only one utterly amazed - of course, I'm not - at the absolute hypocrisy being displayed by the Intolerants? (Yes, I have finally found a name to describe that segment of Americans who are intolerant of racial and cultural diversity, bipartisanship, stricter regulations on big business, and more stringent controls to protect our environment.)

I am disheartened by how reticent the Intolerants have been, not speaking out against the sheer devastation taking place in our nation's Gulf Coast: Literally hundreds of thousands of gallons of oil a day spilling into our precious wetlands, polluting our oyster beds, killing our shrimp harvests and destroying our prime fishing areas. We have not heard a peep of dismay, outrage or fear from them.

And why haven't we? Because it is largely their policies which are to blame. It's Intolerants like Sarah Palin - who, before the Deepwater Horizon's explosion, were enjoining others to chant "Drill, Baby Drill," at rallies in support of more off-shore oil drilling - who, all along, have supported Big Oil and not the land, air and water they pollute. It is the Intolerants who've decried environmental protections. And it is the Intolerants who have turned this country over to Big Business, foreign and domestic like BP.

You see, for the Intolerants to say now that the Gulf oil spill is a bad thing is to admit they've been advocating bad policies all along. And to add insult to injury, Sarah Palin is now going around now, blaming the environmentalists for the spill. Huh?

Why can't the Intolerants just be like the baseball umpire who blew the Perfect Game call? Why can't they just admit they were wrong?

Counterpoint by Ed Holliday

With all due respect to my friend Rev. Hull, my first thought is: excuuuuse me! I have heard from all sides of the political spectrum that this oil leak is a man-made disaster. Sounds like to me Rev. Hull needs to increase his diversity of media sources.

What is shocking is the amount of time it took to get federal leadership to respond to this disaster. This disaster happened in April. State leaders such as Gov. Jindal of Louisiana have been begging for leadership to cut through burdensome federal red-tape from the Army Corps of Engineers, the Environmental Protection Agency and a plethora of other federal government agencies. How long does it take for leadership to emerge?

Even President Obama's moratorium on offshore drilling was cumbersome. Bipartisan efforts had to be used (Rev. Hull, this destroys your theory on the intolerants) to convince the President that he was wrong to force a moratorium on both deep sea and shallow water offshore drilling. The President just this week backed down from his original decision which would have cost the region the further loss of thousands more jobs, more diminished state tax collections, and sent drilling rigs from America to the West African coast.

We do need to learn from this disaster to better enforce regulations and to make conditions safer. But in the economic real world, if our liberal leaders, who control all of Washington today, shut down offshore drilling and continue to keep us away from land sources of oil in the U.S., then gas prices will skyrocket - as will our dependence on Middle Eastern oil. Such liberal policies will lead to a diminished economy that will hurt everyone, but the hard-working middle class and the hard-working poor will suffer the most.

James Hull is an award-winning journalist and consultant. Contact him at hullmultimedia@aol.com. Dr. Ed Holliday is a Tupelo dentist who has written two successful books. Contact him at ed@teaparty.ms.
Comments
(6)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
ABratt
|
June 13, 2010
Neither Hull nor Holliday has touched on the main reason for the Gulf disaster.

Deep Water Horizon should not have been encouraged to drill a well that deep in the Gulf that was subject to a catastophic we-can't- repair-the-damage-soon type scenerio of this magnitude.

But what do you do as an average American about the incompetency of the Bush-Cheney Administration which is to blame for this catastrophe? And also the economic catastrophe that is slowly reducing the American way of life to rubble?

For sure and certain, you don't support the Republican Party or their Tea Party Loonies!!That's guaranteed Wrong-Headedness!
Flemmings
|
June 13, 2010
James Hull's argument doesn’t make sense. He's wanting to blame people like Sara Palin who right now is not elected to anything and of whom I think is overrated and incompetent with deep water drilling which caused the accident in the gulf. Hull then of course enlightens us with his superior intellect by coining the term “Intolerants” to describe of course the only topic he likes to associate every problem with which is some type of racial diversity problem.

This problem is simple: we should not be drilling in deep water because we obviously cannot fix a problem that far below the surface. However I don't notice Hull or anyone else parking their cars and walking around town in order to lower our dependence on oil. We need to all grow up and take responsibility for situations like the oil spill because we are the ones to blame for electing idiots into positions of power that would allow something like this to happen.

Woolhat
|
June 12, 2010
If the only tool you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.

Not original, but I don't know whom to attribute.

The racial grievance lobby in this country is so well entrenched that everything MUST be a racist conspiracy. Otherwise, some of us had better find a REAL job.
MarkJo
|
June 12, 2010
I would cautiously cast stones and call people names if I lived in a glass house where I definitely would not want someone else to call me names for what I've done or currently doing.

I think an honest debate is good, and all points of view should be respectfully considered even if you decide to disagree. Everyone is outraged by the devastation of the oil spill and there is plenty of blame to go around, but how in the world does a discussion of racial and cultural diversity fit into this equation.

anti-state
|
June 12, 2010
It was caused by the "Intolerants" says Hull. What a joke. If he and his hero, Leonard Pitts, didn't have the race card they wouldn't have anything at all. Sadly, Holliday still foolishly believes that the government can do good and protect people as long as it's not corrupted by "liberals."

What gibberish on both sides. Government is only competent to do two things: kill and rob. And guess what Hull? It doesn't give a damn about any colors other than the red blood it spills and the green cash it steals.
fwiw
|
June 12, 2010
These opposing comments are nothing more than the daily spiel from the left and right. Nothing new. Nothing insightful. JUST NOTHING.