Facebook Twitter eEdition Your News Business Directory List Business Classifieds Subscribe NEMisJobs NEMissPreps NEMSHomes NEMSDeals

OPINION: Gay student has rights to suit herself
by Patsy R. Brumfield/NEMS Daily Journal
2 years ago | 470 views | 12 12 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Why, oh why, do school officials think they can change the world if they outlaw some types of personal behavior by their students?

I’m not talking about bans on weapons or local chapters of al-Qaida. In Copiah County, the public school system forbade a gay female student from wearing a tuxedo in her senior yearbook photo.

“The way we’ve always done it” must be that boys wear tuxes and girls wear those lovely draped things, sometimes with a little shoulder showing.

Now, it looks like the schools superintendent wants to take it all the way legally

You’ve got to wonder about a drawn-out fuss, even if they claim they have a legal precedent to back them up.

A young lawyer I know asks two very good questions:

- Is this a battle worth fighting?

- Is this a fight that can be won?

If you answer “no” to either one, it’s worth a re-think.

But when both questions get “no,” what kind of crazy place is that to put yourself?

Copiah guy, this is a yearbook, not the U.S. Army. Uniform dress by sex makes for an appealing look, but it’s hardly worth spending money in court.

Back in my McComb High days, we just used those always lovely, regular school photos. Remember back in the ’60s when in-authority adults got all worked up about Beatles haircuts? Or when guys peroxided the front of their hair?

I remember the day when Ole Miss female students had a 10:30 weeknight curfew and couldn’t wear slacks or jeans on campus, unless they were art students.

I’ve often thought that senior dress-up requirement had more to do with making money for a professional photographer than anything else. Even if that’s the case in Copiah County, the young woman is hardly rabble-rousing. She’s wearing an approved garment. The yearbook gets her photo in accordance with its dress policy, and the pro photog makes money, if her mom wants to purchase prints. In this case, The New York Times may want some.

If I were her classmate, it would make me get my photo re-taken in the sex-approved drape but with blue hair.

About a decade ago, my son’s yearbook adviser called me, furious that he had “ruined” the Brandon annual. My God, I thought, has he set fire to the layouts or something? No, she said, he gave her another middle name for himself instead of his real one, a family name he wasn’t overly happy with at age 17.

Really? I inquired.

Yes, and it had “ruined” the full-color senior section of the book, she repeated, as well as the hallowed composite. Seems he had decided to ensure his immortality in the annals of annuals by inserting the name of his favorite wrestler – Goldberg – where his real middle name should have been. The earth did not stop rotating on its axis because of the joke, and Copiah County will continue to exist, despite a gay young woman’s decision to suit herself rather than others.

Folks, get over it.

Contact Patsy R. Brumfield at (662) 678-1596 or patsy.brumfield@djournal.com. Read Patsy’s blog, From the Front Row, on NEMS360.com.
Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
dfmr
|
March 11, 2010
Fire the decision makers

Stop the State and Federal monies to the school system.

They have no right to discriminate agaist gays/lesbians or race etc.

All who agree ought to flood President Obamas with your opinions on this. And all the media outlets.

It is simply discrimination and the school system is teaching it.
ultracreep
|
October 27, 2009
Scientists, who have nothing whatsoever to do with Al Gore, will tell you about rising temperatures and drowning polar bears. When you have to swim to your mailbox every morning, Bichon, perhaps that will mean something to you. The idea of "catching gay" is absurd in the extreme and also undermines the whole "it's a choice" argument that the so-called "Christian" right espouses.If it's a choice, it isn't exactly contagious now is it? Pick one ridiculous theory and stick with it. Bottom line is, gay people have the right to be who they are, whether you like it or not. The end.
Bichon
|
October 25, 2009
I am happy to learn that you watch fox news. At least you will be exposed to some truth and ethics.

I guess Al Gore told you that the polar cap is melting? Have you been there??? I thought not!!

I also have no idea what you have or have not caught. I have not caught the swine flu but I do not want to be exposed.

I do want the polar bears protected because they were put on earth to make me a fur coat.

Global warming is an Al Gore religion and he has made millions parading arround in his private jet while trying to force me to drive a tin can.

As usual, I just want to share my thoughts with intelligent folks who can make up their own minds about whether they want to catch "GAY'.
ultracreep
|
October 25, 2009
Way to make no sense and use an obscure word from Bill O' Reilly's nightly "make yourself sound pretentious" spot, Bichon. I knew I could count on you. If gay were catching, I'd be the queerest person I know and I'm totally straight. There goes that ancient and completely untrue hypothesis. As for global warming, please explain to the drowning polar bears, melting ice floes, and rising ocean temperatures that they're just the results of some misguided zealotry,I'm sure that will clear it right up.
Bichon
|
October 25, 2009
Evolution, gay rights, and global warming etc.etc. are jusr religious zealots pushing their religion while screaming separation of church and state.

They believe in anything that takes GOD out of schools and our America.

The real problem in our society are those that would laugh when their children lie and disobey school policy just to make a statement.

It is creepy, but true "gay is catching". Gays cannot naturally reproduce, so how come there are so many of them??

I thought schools were supposed to have rules and regulations designed to make better citizens, not to encourage perverted ideas.

It seems many journalist and some other folks just bloviate to be provocative.

scar-strangled-banter
|
October 25, 2009
Why can't she show her tits? I'm sure she's 18.Honestly, honestly, I can't believe this is being discussed. who freaking cares? So she hates dresses, why is it the principal's business? If he's concerned with society, why not ban mullets?
BFD
|
October 23, 2009
she should wear a tuxedo shirt. it says she wants to be formal but is also here to party
ultracreep
|
October 23, 2009
Why does anyone care, as long as she's fully covered, and the outfit is formal? All this getting hung up in gender or sexuality is just dumb. You're not going to magically make her straight or feminine by putting her in a dress. This essentially boils down to people disapproving of homosexuality. Sure you can disapprove, but I think at this point, trying to stick them back in the closet is just not gonna work. Let the girls wear suits and the boys wear skirts if they want to. It's not like the whole class is going to "catch gay" because one chick wears a suit. I'm secure enough in who I am to not be concerned with what other people wear, so long as all the naughty bits are covered. In another decade or so, this will probably be fairly common. They have the right to be who they are.
PontotocRebel
|
October 22, 2009
"She’s wearing an approved garment. The yearbook gets her photo in accordance with its dress policy,..."

It was my understanding that the dress policy was specific to gender in its requirements. I do not have a copy of their policy, and couldn't find one on the net, but if the policy is that way then "she" could not have possibly been wearing an "approved" garment....

Either way....what's next? You want the school to change out every door knob because one student only wants to open doors with triangular shaped knobs?

This is ridiculous...I'm glad the school is standing their ground!!!!

missdem
|
October 22, 2009
Great article and right on target in regard to the issue. The arc of history favors respect and dignity for human beings but this isn't automatic. Your article helps.
Bichon
|
October 22, 2009
Really Ms Patsy for the degenerates of society?

Just look at the progress we have made since we got so politically correct.

We should all just forget our morals and traditions and give the radicals and rebel rousers all the publicity they desire.

A high school lesbian? COME ON

I think moral folks are nt quite ready to GET OVER IT!!!

Why not write something sensible and try to get over being the opiate for the jackasses
gyrbr
|
October 22, 2009
I think the student should dress like a girl for the photo. Other people have rights to.